Friendly, personal, experienced agents from a name you can trust!

Office Exterior
The most important “benefit” for you to have in today’s challenging insurance environment is peace of mind. Ryan St. Marie Insurance Agency provides that peace of mind knowing you have the right coverage at an affordable price. When you have a serious concern, a claim issue, or just a simple coverage question, you know who to call. If you would like to speak to one of our agents face to face about an issue or a question you may have, feel free to stop by our office in Elyria, Ohio.

Your needs will be addressed promptly, properly, and professionally. It is the high level of personal service and industry know-how that we possess that will provide you with the peace of mind that you deserve and expect.

Anyone can give you an insurance quote, even a faceless electronic blip on the Internet. Your needs are unique. We don’t want to simply give you a quote; we want to understand your needs when it comes to auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance and business insurance. Our employees live in your community and want you to be a client year after year.

The comprehensive services that you receive from Ryan-St. Marie go far beyond a mere keystroke – insurance is not something you buy once and forget about. We will show you a variety of plans, explain the benefits and potential shortcomings of all of them, and assist you with the selection of a plan that fits your coverage and budget requirements.

Our Insurance Services

Auto
Insurance

Auto Insurance Box

Home
Insurance

Home Insurance Box

Life
Insurance

Life Insurance Box

Business
Insurance

Business Insurance Box

What Our Clients Say

Ryan-St. Marie Insurance Agency Inc
Ryan-St. Marie Insurance Agency Inc
27 Google reviews
Leslie Richards
Leslie Richards
2023-07-18
In August of 2021, my basement flooded due to the heavy rains we received. I was extremely thankful when I called my agent, Mindy, and discovered I was covered. My mother was not so lucky. My mother is still working on the repairs in her basement. While I was sitting back, watching the repairs in my house be completed. We had a few hiccups during the repair process with the claims adjustor, but when I called Mindy, she was on the ball, and the problem was fixed immediately. Mindy is the most knowledgeable, caring, and honest agent. She has been my agent for 10+ years and is the only agent I trust. Thank you Mindy for always having my back.
Jessica Wyatt
Jessica Wyatt
2023-07-11
Mindy is wonderful! Extremely knowledgeable and caring. So grateful to have her on my side!
Murray Brown
Murray Brown
2023-06-30
They're the best!
Casey Martin
Casey Martin
2023-06-02
Mindy has helped my nonprofit with insurance questions and policy reviews on two occasions now, and provided valuable advice, even though initially, the advice was to continue with the insurance I had rather than her quotes. The second time I asked for advice, I was able to go through her, and I'm so glad it worked out that way! She even offered to come to board meetings if ever needed, to explain the nuances of the policy to the board. Amazing customer service!
Sue Watkins
Sue Watkins
2023-02-02
Working with Mindy was stress-free, easy, and delightful! She made me feel at ease as she worked behind the scenes to get my questions answered and make sure that I had my business completely covered. I highly recommend working with Mindy!
Mike Dobson
Mike Dobson
2023-01-19
The staff was great
Roger Karnatz
Roger Karnatz
2022-02-21
Needed info on my policy and they answer all questions promptly.
Kristin Watkins
Kristin Watkins
2022-01-15
Great people, great service
Leave Us A Review

Ryan St. Marie Insurance

Hours

  • Monday-Friday: 9:00am – 5:00pm EST
  • Extended hours available by appointment
Our agency is licensed in the state of Ohio.