Friendly, personal, experienced agents from a name you can trust!

Office Exterior
The most important “benefit” for you to have in today’s challenging insurance environment is peace of mind. Ryan St. Marie Insurance Agency provides that peace of mind knowing you have the right coverage at an affordable price. When you have a serious concern, a claim issue, or just a simple coverage question, you know who to call. If you would like to speak to one of our agents face to face about an issue or a question you may have, feel free to stop by our office in Elyria, Ohio.

Your needs will be addressed promptly, properly, and professionally. It is the high level of personal service and industry know-how that we possess that will provide you with the peace of mind that you deserve and expect.

Anyone can give you an insurance quote, even a faceless electronic blip on the Internet. Your needs are unique. We don’t want to simply give you a quote; we want to understand your needs when it comes to auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance and business insurance. Our employees live in your community and want you to be a client year after year.

The comprehensive services that you receive from Ryan-St. Marie go far beyond a mere keystroke – insurance is not something you buy once and forget about. We will show you a variety of plans, explain the benefits and potential shortcomings of all of them, and assist you with the selection of a plan that fits your coverage and budget requirements.


Most recently, when I bought a new car, I had an updated insurance card to take with me to the dealer when I signed the papers. Talk about an immediate response!
~Ken G., customer since 2020

Ryan St. Marie has always taken care of my insurance. They are knowledgeable in the market and know how to take care of you. They are there whenever you need and treat you like family.
~Gregory H., customer since 2018

“I have been a customer for many years, been through several life changes with them, and have even gone through a car accident with their support. I can’t imagine there being a better company to have by my side!”
~ Rebecca Gorek
“Spencer was very easy to reach and very prompt with his responses. He and his staff are courteous and helpful. Spencer explained everything clearly and was patient. Additionally, he came to my parents house (also clients) to meet with them one-on-one, which I think is a nice, personal touch. “
~ Kathryn Machcinski
“We recently were on a family vacation in South Carolina and unfortunately were involved in a car accident which was not our fault and our vehicle was totaled. Due to the fact that we were so far away from home, our vehicle was a total and the at-fault driver’s insurance coverage was “in question”, we decided to file a claim through our insurance – Westfield Insurance Company. We can not say enough about how well and how quickly our claim was handled! Our Westfield adjuster was awesome! So thankful, under our circumstances, that we had good coverage and a great company to work with!”
~ Joseph A. LaGrotteria
“Mindy Nielsen checks all of the boxes: Great service, personable, professional, and reliable. Add that Ryan-St. Marie offers competitive products and rates and you have one great combination.” 
~Joel L.
“They have always been available and answered any questions I have had!!”
~Stephanie C.

Spencer and his team have been super helpful from start to finish on taking care of my insurance needs. I feel more informed as a consumer now and would recommend Ryan St. Marie Insurance to anyone!
~Brian Y., customer since 2020

Phone calls are quickly returned and everyone goes above and beyond to make sure your need are addressed timely.
~Nicole J., customer since 2018

“Your staff have treated us extremely well. They have found us ways to reduce our premiums without sacrificing protection. You get the feeling they are treating you like their own family when they make recommendations. I’ve been a customer since I bought my first vehicle, over 30 years ago. We moved out of the Elyria area over 25 years ago, but I’ve never even considered looking for a new agent. (Thank you Jeannie and the others, for all the help over the years!)”
~ Richard Schmittgen Jr
“Your staff is professional. They are quick to respond to questions and concerns. They are also great at understanding our insurance needs. “
~ Brian Karl
“I am so pleased that I looked into getting insurance policies for my home and auto through Ryan St. Marie. I had Geico for both and ended up saving 30% on both by switching (over $650/yr). Plus, the service is much more personal with RSM. Be sure to ask for Teresa Sabo. She is awesome!”
~ Jesse S.
“It’s been great to work with Ryan-St. Marie Agency! We had a chance to save a few dollars last year when comparing other providers, but the value of the customer service received FAR exceeds a few dollars in savings. Their rates are competitive, but it’s the customer service that makes them GREAT!! Thanks Ryan-St. Marie!!”
~LeeAnn L.
“Spencer and his team here are top notch! Great experience making the switch to them and even with my first (unfortunate) claim. Highly recommend!!”
~Brian Y.

Ryan St. Marie Insurance


  • Monday-Friday: 9:00am – 5:00pm EST
  • Extended hours available by appointment
Our agency is licensed in the state of Ohio.